A couple of years ago, when this blog had around 300 subscribers, a friend asked me why I seemed to be promoting it heavily. The answer I gave him was somewhat waffly, but boiled down to the fact that I thought I could get to a place where I had (a) 1,000 – 5,000 subscribers, with a nice commenting community; (b) would have some level of minor influence in terms of being read by people in the political/policy-making/journalistic community; (c) could make a few thousand pounds a year from it.
And it struck me recently, with over 2600 subscribers, that I’ve done it! That I am now one of the merry band of us, mainly amateurs, in the middle league: those of us with between 1,000 and 10,000 subscribers (what I’ve previously termed a ‘Tier 3 blog’).1 Far from ‘big beasts’, but also a long way beyond just being read by your mum, your best mate and his dog.
I see a great many people starting a Substack/blog - and a bunch who consider it. I’ve had several recently ask my advice on how to do it. And while we all hope we’ll be the next Scott Alexander, writing globally influential thought-pieces and pulling in half a million a year for it, realistically, the middle-league is a far more attainable goal: one that many people, with a bit of talent and a fair bit more effort, could attain.
So this is my guide on making it to the middle league. But before we go, we should be clear about what this means.
The middle league is not a place which will let you give up the day job, or make you rich and famous. I’m not saying forget about those dreams - but to get there, you’ll probably need to do something different.2 But what being in the middle does give you is still worthwhile:
An audience in the thousands for anything you write - with no editor and no-one telling you what you can and can’t cover.
A small community - both those who comment, and other bloggers in the middle league in your subject area, who you may be directly or indirectly in dialogue with.
A level of influence and recognition. Depending on what you write about, the form of this may vary, but I’ve been cited in the Financial Times, Spectator, Telegraph, the i Paper and more, as well as getting a book contract out of it.
A bit of extra income - perhaps enough to pay for an annual holiday, or to cover the cost of replacing your car every few years. Not enough to make you rich, but more than beer money.3
Crucially, it’s compatible with a full-time job and family commitments. There are exceptions, but for most people I see with subscriber numbers well above the middle league, blogging is their primary job. This guide is deliberately written to be achievable by someone who spends 2-4 hours a week blogging.
So without further ado, here goes.
Keep writing. By far the most common pattern I see is someone who starts a Substack, writes a few interesting pieces and then…stops. Occasionally there’s a final piece a few months later, a last gasp of life before the curtain falls. Whether that’s jotting down ideas you have for posts so you’ll remember them for later, or seizing the moment to write something if you have a spare hour, keep writing.
Write regularly. All the advice says that it’s best to write to a regular pattern, publishing something on the same day(s) of the week every week. If other commitments in your life mean you can’t do that (I don’t), then still try to keep up a regular frequency, such as publishing at least once a week (which I largely do manage).
Be patient. It took me eight months to reach 100 subscribers, two years to reach 500 and a further two years to reach 2500.4 That’s about 200 posts, or c. 500 hours of writing.5 Don’t expect your journey to be linear, either: there can be months where you only just break even, and other times when a single post gets you 100 new subscribers.6
Get over the hump. You may have things you want to write, but if you’re anything like me, you’ll sometimes find that reading a book, watching TV or playing a game feels more appealing. Find a way of overcoming that hump - whether it’s a ritual with a favourite drink, a certain time of day for writing or a particular playlist you write to - and don’t stop writing until it finishes. For me, I find if I jot out the skeleton in the post one day, it is much easier to come in the next and get writing - because mentally I feel I’ve ‘already done the thinking’.
Know what your blog is about. Is it about politics? About books? About parenting and family life? About fashion? A clear focus will make it easier both to attract readers - and to keep them. There’s a degree of flexibility here - I’m fairly sure I’m far less focused than is optimal - but even there, it’s clear this is mainly a blog about politics and public policy, with a focus on education, and a sideline in social issues and book reviews.
‘Hot takes’ only go so far. Who doesn’t like writing hot takes? We all succumb upon occasion. But unless you’re one of those supremely gifted people who can regularly give your readers a genuinely new perspective on something,7 there’s a limit to how many readers you’ll keep with your opinion alone. Posts which provide information, that inform and educate, such that even someone who disagrees with you will get something from it, are a stronger foundation for success.8
Know your audience. People subscribed to you for a reason. Make sure you continue to give them enough of what they signed up for. That doesn’t mean every post has to be targeted at it: it’s your blog, and you should feel free to indulge yourself and write about what you want to - or what you care about. But I know that most people aren’t here for my theories on Sanderson’s Stormlight Archive - so while I will write that piece, I’ll know to follow it up fairly soon with a good public policy post.9
But don’t be captured by it. There was a moment when I had about 1000 subscribers when I found myself doubting whether I should post a book review. But then I reflected that I started blogging partly to be able to write about books I liked! By all means think about pleasing your audience - but if you ever find yourself not writing something you want to, or writing something you don’t, then give yourself a good hard shake and get back to what you should be doing.
Don’t sell your soul. It might seem tempting to maximise engagement by adopting more and more strident views about a subject - whether that’s partisan politics, the culture wars or one side or another of any controversial topic. Don’t do this. Pragmatically, of the many who try this route, all of them wreck their integrity but only a very few make it big - it’s the OnlyFans gambit for writers. But more importantly, you are what you write. It’s impossible to write hate-filled (from any perspective) bile week-in, week-out, without it changing what you believe. There was a horrendous story a few years back about a food influencer who discovered he could get huge audiences by gorging in front of the camera and became horrendously obese; those who allow the lure of clicks to lead them down the spiralling path of extremism may be surrendering their minds, rather than their bodies, but the end result is no prettier.
Seize the moment. Sometimes a topic you’ve been meaning to write about is suddenly in the news. If this happens, ignore whatever you’d been planning to write about next and write about that topic instead - linking your ideas to what everyone wants to hear about. I’m not saying slavishly follow the discourse - you’re not writing a daily newspaper column - but don’t let an opportunity slide by, either.
Do things that will go beyond your existing audience. Try to do things that people will actively want to share. I’ve run fun surveys on who people consider rich, or which professions they see as virtuous, established an annual forecasting contest and made a political quiz for right-wing archetypes. They were all things I thought would be fun to do - but they all brought new audiences in, too. Find what works for you, and do it.
Promote yourself. No matter how good your writing, no-one’s going to find your blog if you don’t promote it. This means having some presence on one or more major social media sites - and you’ll need to be at least somewhat active there, not just sharing links to your blog. As a politics and policy blog, I share on X, Bluesky and LinkedIn; I presume a fashion blog would do better on Instagram - but wherever you choose, you’ve got to be there.
Share others’ work generously. Share other people’s work regularly, generously and without expectation of return. Give, and it will be returned to you - perhaps not by those whose work you shared, but by someone. No-one likes a miser, or someone who only promotes their own work.
Use Recommendations. Substack’s ‘Recommendations’ feature creates a powerful network effect. Around 15% of my subscribers have come from Recommendations. If there are other people on Substack writing in a similar space, particularly if you know them or they’re subscribed to you, and have similar subscriber numbers (say, a factor of 3 smaller or larger),10 , don’t hesitate to message them to suggest that you mutually ‘Recommend’ each other.11
Don’t go paid too early. Far fewer people will read paywalled posts - which means you have a much lower number of potential sharers. I would strongly recommend against going paid before 1,000 subscribers (I went at 2,000). Once you do go paid, there is a direct trade-off between monetisation and growth.12
Tier 0 (1 - 9): You have a blog! Well done! It’s read by your mum, your brother and your best mate.
Tier 1 (10 - 99): Tribal bard. Your readership is in the tens, mainly people you know and see regularly, plus perhaps a few others.
Tier 2 (100 - 999): Small community. Your blog is read by hundreds of people, including many people you don’t know. You’ve broken out of your ‘personal contacts’ space. In the grand scheme of things though, it’s still pretty small.
Tier 3 (1,000 - 9,999): Large community. Thousands of people read your blog every week. You’re likely to be known and cited within a particular specialism, field or hobby, though probably not outside it.
Tier 4 (10,000 - 99,999): Global or national reach. Tens of thousands of people read your blog; it will be shared many times each week. It’s likely that some of those readers are influential, or speak of it to others. Yours is a name that other people may have heard of, in that if someone says, ‘I was reading X’s blog’ to a stranger, they might know of it.
Or be very lucky, or even more talented.
On all of these, there is, fairly obviously, a big difference between being at 1,000 subscribers and being at 9,000. But these are broadly true across this range.
If you begin as a celebrity, as a well-known national journalist or as someone with 50,000+ followers on X/Instagram/etc then your journey may be quicker.
For comparison, I only have 343 hour logged on Stellaris, admittedly over a longer time period.
Particularly between 500-1000 subscribers, I had a counterintuitive phenomenon where I’d gain subscribers during the week and immediately lose a few when I posted. This makes sense - getting an email with an ‘unsubscribe’ button reminds people they want to quit - but even if it wasn’t obvious, those posts were still doing something: satisfying my existing audience and gradually building up a reputation as someone worth reading.
Roll up, Scott Alexander, who gave us the Toxoplasma of Rage, the concepts of Bounded Distrust and Scissor Statements, Heuristics that Almost Always Work and many more.
Even a polemic post, such as my Rage, Rage, Against the Growing of the Debt, can be written to provide a fair bit of new information to the reader.
This can also apply to writing about controversial subjects. Bret Devereaux has a good maxim that engagement is about building capital, whereas activism is about spending it. I have written about controversial subjects, such as trans or Israel, and one benefit of having a blog that isn’t mainly about those subjects means that a bunch of people who might not normally read that perspective will be exposed to it. But equally, I’m aware that if I wrote about them all the time, I’d be spending capital faster than I was building it, and start losing readers.
I think only approach really big beasts for this if you’re confident they’d count you as a genuine friend. But someone of a similar size can just be an acquaintance/professional contact/mutual subscriber.
And on that note, if anyone with their own Substack would like to add me to their Recommendations list, I would be a most grateful recipient! I give a complimentary free subscription to anyone with over 1000 subscribers who is recommending me.

